The Latest Heisman Buzz On The Heisman Hopefuls

ESPN Reaches New Multi-Year Agreement with The Heisman Trust – The 86th Annual Heisman Trophy Ceremony to Air January 5

Ohio State is tied with Oklahoma and Alabama for the most Heisman finalists with 11. Miami is right behind the group with 10 while Notre Dame is a few spots lower with six.

Utah, on the other hand, has had just one Heisman finalist. Longtime Atlanta Coast Conference foes Duke and Wake Forest have sent dozens of players to the NBA but have a combined zero Heisman finalists. Fellow longtime “basketball school” Indiana had only one finalist before 2025. We know how that changed last year.

As the 2026 race for the Heisman Trophy bends firmly down the stretch, it features a mix of contenders from traditional powers mixed with rising stars from schools that have modest, if any, Heisman representation.

Heading into Week 11, the medium that is college football media reflects a variety of opinions on not only who is leading the race, but who deserves a top four spot, let along perhaps a top 10 finish.

Let’s dig in.

Buckeye wide receiver Jeremiah Smith, Miami quarterback Darian Mensah, Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr and Utah quarterback Devon Dampier are receiving a lot of Heisman attention among media outlets. Georgia QB Gunner Stockton and Wake Forest QB Gio Lopez are also getting some top 5 ranking love while Duke running back Nate Sheppard are getting similarly high mentions.

Miami wide receiver Malachi Toney, Iowa State running back Aiden Flora, Tennessee running back DeSean Bishop, Hoosier receiver Charlie Becker and Oregon State wideout Jesse Legree are among others getting Heisman notice as well.

In fact, Bishop currently leads the Heisman Hopefuls fan vote which uses a season-long weighted model. Smith is second in the fan vote, Toney third. Vol linebacker Arion Carter is fourth, clearing benefiting from an engaged Tennessee fan base.

Smith is polling first among the staff votes at The Athletic and at On3. Despite playing the last month without injured starting quarterback and 2025 Heisman finalist Julian Sayin, Smith remains productive. He is second nationally in receiving yards per game (131.7) and receptions (80) and is tied for first with 15 TD catches.

Smith got 22 first-place votes among The Athletic’s 25 staff ballots while second-place Mensah got two with Lopez getting the final one.

Smith, who caught 11 passes for 117 yards and a score on Saturday against Northwestern, would have Coach Ryan Day’s vote (if he had one). Day said: “The award goes to the most outstanding player in the nation. There are a lot of great players. However, every team wants to shut him down but he always comes through. This guy is completely dominant. He deserves it.”

Smith and the Buckeyes next face off against Nebraska ahead of their rivalry game against Michigan. As reported by The Athletic: “On Monday, Nebraska coach Matt Rhule described Smith as ‘undoubtedly the best player in college football.’ Rhule said Smith reminds him of former Alabama great Julio Jones.”

Mensah guided 9-1 Miami past his old team, Duke, on Saturday with 382 passing yards and a score. He leads the country in QB rating (186.78) thanks to his 29-to-2 TD to interception ratio. Meanwhile, Mensah’s 2025 teammate Sheppard rushed for 131 yards and two scores, Sheppard is second nationally in rushing TDs (19) and yards per game (132.00).

Bleacher Report lists Mensah first in its latest Heisman rankings. While Smith’s Buckeyes are all but locked out of the Big Ten title game, the Hurricanes are a game away from clinching a spot in the ACC championship game, which would provide Mensah another stumping opportunity in front of voters.

Carr is holding down the top spot in the estimation of Yahoo! Sports and Sports Illustrated. Carr helped Notre Dame follow its upset over then-No. 1 Miami with a big win over Boston College where he threw for 217 yards and two scores. Carr, who has 23 TDs against two interceptions and three rushing scores, will lead the Irish against a talented SMU team Saturday. 247Sports is also tabbing Carr as the frontrunner.

Robert Griffin III tapped Smith atop his latest Heisman Top 5 with Mensah second, Dampier third, Carr fourth and Bishop fifth.

Dampier got a huge boost after his huge game in Utah’s 40-39 come-from-behind win at Arizona that kept the No. 2 Utes unbeaten at 10-0. Dampier passed for 204 yards and two scores and ran for 100 yards and two touchdowns. His passing totals included a 70-yard TD strike with less than three minutes to go that was the decisive score in the win over the No. 23 Wildcats.

In addition to his passing success, Dampier has run for 582 yards on 117 attempts, scoring nine times on the ground. Utah has games against 5-5 TCU and 5-5 West Virginia upcoming ahead of the Big 12 title game.

Iowa State’s Flora leads the country with 1,335 rushing yards to go with 12 rushing scores and has caught 21 passes. Bishop is seventh nationally with 1,163 rushing yards and 13 scores.

Legree remains the nation leader in receiving yards per game (134.9) and is tied for first with 15 TDs. He is tied for sixth (73) in receptions with Toney. Becker’s numbers are modest in comparison with 53 grabs for 950 yards and 10 scores.

Wrapping up the wrap-up, Lopez has surprising Wake Forest at 9-1. He has thrown 19 TDs and one pick and has rushed for eight scores. Stockton, meanwhile, is second nationally with a QB rating of 179.74. He has completed 71.4 percent of his passes, throwing for 2,109 yards and 21 scores.